Saturday, April 7, 2012

Killing the Innocents



Ever noticed the immense love of a mother for her new born?? And ever did it come in your wildest of imagination that the same loving, caring mother could have killed an unborn child in her womb? Well, I am not telling you to imagine a hypothetical situation. It's very real. So, did you ever wonder what made the same mother be two totally different person (murderer, and caring mother) in two different situations?? I hope not. But let's ponder over it, because the situation is frighteningly bad and we have been following ostrich approach till now.

A famous saying in Sanskrit goes- " यत्र नार्यस्तु पूजयन्ते, रमन्ते तत्र देवता" (where women is worshipped, there lives GOD). But unfortunately, here in our country, many people are so inhumane that forget worshipping women, they ruthlessly ensure that there is no female arrival in the family. And surprising fact is that womenfolk themselves play a key role in this!! What can be more ironic than the fact that female population is working to finish off their own gender!!

When I look around myself and ask myself as to what most I would like to change, I find a very clear answer- "female foeticide". I want to see a complete stop to this evil practice carried around in society. Ending a speechless, defenseless life is the height of cruelty. I wonder how come this savage practice still prevalent in our society. 

According to a report, estimates of the number of female fetuses being destroyed every year vary from two million to five millions. Even if we assume it to be just two millions, then every minute, 4 innocent lives are being terminated illegally. As per the provisional 2011 Census report, Child sex ratio (0-6 yrs) has declined from 927 females against 1000 males in 2001, to 914 females against 1000 males in 2011. In fact Haryana and Punjab at the bottom of ladder are having frighteningly low ratio with 830 and 846 females respectively (against 1000 males). And, can you believe it, a 2005 New York Times article estimates the number of missing girls to be 50 million. (missing means missing in numbers compared to male population). 

So can you imagine how much social mayhem will be unleashed by such vast gender gap?? Increasing number of sexual assaults on females are already being witnessed. Apart from that, there are many more grave issues cropping up like trafficking of females for prostitution, buying of brides from higher sex ratio regions , wife sharing with multiple brothers etc.


So you see where it is leading to?? A monstrous, savage society, where the few leftover females too will be ruthlessly mauled by human vultures. A 2003 movie-“Matrubhoomi: A Nation Without Women”, very correctly depicts  that kind of frightening situation in which the female protagonist is subjected to all kind inhumane tortures. 

In 2008, the UN announced that the number of ‘missing’ women in India had climbed to 62 million. As the famous activist Rita Banerji, writes in her report- “What this means in terms of India's social reality is that there are at least 62 million males without hope of ever finding female partners from within their own cultural setting. The possibility of social mayhem under such conditions is terrifying — and what it would involve could lead to widespread sexual crimes, perversion, and near anarchical law-and-order situations.
      
So you see, the issue of female foeticide has reached an alarmingly dangerous level. We have to act to stop it and we have to act NOW.

Now, point is, how to stop this evil practice?

On legal front there are already so many laws to stop this evil practice. The PNDT Act was specifically enacted  to check female foeticide. It not only prohibits determination and disclosure of the sex of foetus, but also prohibits any advertisements related to pre- natal determination of sex.To counter the sex-selective abortions, there is MTP Act which lays down clear conditions under which abortions can be performed.

But do these laws work? NO, because there is severe failure in their implementation. Executive machinery is highly lethargic and judicial process moves at snail's pace. But even strict legal implementation alone may not be sufficient. It will only reduce the practice, not eradicate it completely. For complete eradication, we will have to change the psyche of people involved in the heinous crime. In short, we have to find a full-proof, socio-legal remedy to this evil.

Talking of social aspect, we will have to look at the root cause. In this case, there are multiple causes. Here are some major ones-
  • Dowry- a girl child means you have to save lacs of rupees for her dowry.
  • A medieval thinking that a boy child  carries the family name (generation) forward but girl child can't!!
  • A (mis)conception that only a boy child can perform the last riots properly, helping parents gain salvation!!
  • More expenses and care needed in bringing up a girl child.
  • Girl child is "paraye ghar ki amanat"(asset of "other" family). She has to go one day. On the other hand, male child is "budhape ka sahara" (old-age support), expenses incurred over a boy child is a good investment!!

So you can see, female foeticide is driven by age-old customs, patriarchal, medieval thinking. Our society is unfairly biased towards male child. There is vast inequality between male and female sections of society. According to the recent Human Development Report 2011, India ranks 129 out of 146 countries on the Gender Inequality Index, below even Bangladesh and Pakistan. 

The solution lies in convincing people to reform their mentality, which undoubtedly, is a mammoth task. Nevertheless, this mammoth task has to be completed if we don't wish to face an extremely alarming, “Matrubhoomi” like situation. 

Out of the above few reasons cited, Dowry is the biggest driving factor for female foeticide. Having a girl child feels like a burden, a liability, all thanks to the ingrained Dowry culture in the society. Love marriage is still a taboo thing for most sections of society, and in arranged marriages, dowry has become a norm- you want your daughter married, then pay n lacs of rupees, or else keep searching in the dark. Arranged marriages have become a business deal, you pay the price (dowry) or the deal won't go through. If dowry culture ends, then I am sure there will be more than 75% decline in the female foeticide cases. So eradication of Dowry culture should be our first target.

There are also so many dowry related laws but as I mentioned earlier, existing laws are not properly implemented. Moreover, laws alone can't eradicate an evil which has been persisting for decades. We have to bring about a complete psychological change in our society, and for that we will have to rely more on ourselves than on our legal system. But how to change this ingrained Dowry mentality? I am putting forward a few suggestions regarding this-

  • First, we should TALK. We should talk about it with our friends, our elders, our colleagues, in short, with everyone around us. The biggest mistake that we commit, is not talk about it. I have seen on my facebook page that very few comments come in dowry related posts, whereas a post evoking religious sentiments or a post evoking patriotic sentiments get a volley of comments. People think it's useless to talk about it (or may be they have nothing to talk!!). We have to keep in mind that if we don't talk about it, then it is going to stay here. So we should  talk about it everywhere we can, opposing it in the strongest terms.
  • People should volunteer not to take dowry. I suggest we should make a matrimonial website where everyone promising NOT to accept and give dowry should get registered. We can publicize the site on various city's facebook fan pages (by asking their admins to support the initiative). If a NO DOWRY marriage is solemnized via that platform, then the bride-groom pair and their parents should be felicitated by a district level administrative officer for the nice example set in front of the society. The marriage should also be reported in local newspapers as a heroic act, so that it inspires others too.
  • Religious leaders should be consulted for help. We should request them to include detailed talk on evils of dowry in their religious preachings. The aim should be to convince people that taking dowry is a sinful act. Ours being a predominantly religious society, this is definitely going to have significant affect.
  • We should rally for forcing Govt. to  include dowry in school syllabus. The chapter on dowry should ideally contain a powerful story which should be able to leave a deep impression on children's minds. The aim should be to sow the seeds of morality in small,growing up minds. Taking dowry is morally wrong, and it should be established in the minds of youngsters as early as possible.
  • We youth should step forward. India is a country of youth. According to reports, the average Indian will be only 29 years old in 2020. Youth are known for their innovative ideas, enthusiastic working style, and a never-say-die spirit. We should take the lead in this war against dowry. We should promise that we will try our best to convince our parents not to demand dowry. We, on our own part, should take an oath that in future, when we have children, we won't indulge in this evil practice. We will neither take nor give dowry. This way, even if our parents' generation fails to put an end to dowry, we, in our generation's time, can expect a significant decline in the practice.

Well, these were just some suggestions which can be effective tools in the war against dowry. There can be many more such initiatives, but bottom line is that we should be motivated enough to fight this well-ingrained dowry mentality in society.

Apart from these, there is of course the need to totally overhaul our executive machinery. Police administration needs to take a proactive approach in tackling dowry, rather than the present lethargically-reactive approach. There should be region-wise police teams to make quick raids in suspected dowry cases (without even waiting for complaint from either side). Police should instill fear in the minds of dowry supporters. Dowry laws should be enforced with seriousness.

Eradication of dowry will automatically lead to eradication of female foeticide. Other causes of female foeticide are far less serious and will be taken care of by education. Already, urban masses seem not biased towards male child, and are also shedding their patriarchal mentality. Only the dowry factor still persists everywhere, so it needs to be focussed upon. 

Govt. too needs to make effective regulations to counter female foeticide. It should be ensured that diagnostic tests are not misused for pre-natal gender determination. Doctors caught performing illegal abortions (and hence violating the MTP Act) should be dealt with seriously, their practicing license should be suspended  immediately. All the related existent laws  need to be seriously implemented. And for that, we too need to put pressure on Govt., so that female foeticide becomes one of the priority for Govt. The 50 million missing campaign  by Rita Banerji   is one such laudable campaign.  

Still, very little is being done by us. People just don't  take the female foeticide issue seriously. They think that there are just some isolated cases. They forget that most of the sex-selective abortions are done in a quite hush-hush condition, which, only few close friends and relatives come to know of. People take myopic view of their surroundings and become content thinking that there is just a few cases of female foeticide around them. This is our biggest challenge, and this is what I want to overcome first. We need to make people realize that female foeticide is really rampant in our society and it is an extremely serious issue. We must get prepared to tackle this challenge quickly, or else the day is not far when we will face "Matrubhoomi" like situation.

 Let's Arise, Awake, Act..... and ACT NOW.....

(If you liked this post then please share it with your friends, so that the ideas expressed here could spread fast. And do leave your feedback in the comment section below, add up your own views  if possible, because a healthy discussion is very necessary on such issues. Thanks)

P.S.- Author of this blog-post is Shantinath Chaudhary and he can be contacted at - shantissst@gmail.com 
This blog-post had also been submitted for the Stayfree "Time to Change" contest on indiblogger.

22 comments:

  1. Nice.. very very thought provoking post.. enjoyed it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Kajal: Hi kajal, thanks you so much for appreciating this post. The "thought provoking" term used by you felt so fulfilling and satisfying, because that's what is the purpose of this post. I want everyone reading this post to ponder and then ACT on the issue.... thanks, keep coming back :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Replies
    1. thanks a lot :) feels nice to know that my post was able to leave an impact :)

      Delete
  4. "Dowry" isn't a tradition. It is a stain on society. A dark red stain. It is responsible for killing beautiful babies. You've spoken the absolute truth. It must be stopped. I wonder why girls in this day and age even agree to marry into families that think they, by themselves, are not good enough? Why don't they urge their parents to give them the dowry money and start a business instead? I think a successful business woman protected and loved by her parents will feel more fulfilled and be safer from dowry deaths than being the general dogsbody of the groom's family.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks for appreciating my views, and yes, you have put across a good point- why don't girls refuse to marry in to a dowry taking family.Well, actually its quite complicated here, in tradional arranged marriages, girls and boys have very limited participation in decision making, and being morally inclined to obey their parents' wishes, they are quite unlikely to deny marrying into a particular family, that to based on dowry issue... that's because it might end up into the finalising of girls' marriage dragging on for too long, because dowry-less marriage is a rare thing in most regions of India... Also, an unmarried girl in a family, feels like a shameful thing in Indian family (to the Indian parents), people keep asking about marriage, and parents feel burdened about it. In short, in tradional Indian families, parents take it as their duty to marry off their daughters after a particular age, and in order to fulfill their duty, they pay the dowry.... solution lies in changing this very mentality, which again, is a quite tough task... but let's work together to change the mentality of society...

      Delete
    2. Today there are many girls who have the guts to refuse being put up for sale like that. But I can see why some parents give in. Also, to be fair, many, from the groom's side refuse to accept any dowry. Whether they like it or not, the greedy have to accept that this "tradition" is ugly and many Indians have started thinking so.

      Delete
    3. Yes, it feels nice to know that many groom's families are refusing to accept dowry, but I would say such cases are still meager as compared to the dowry cases. Actually dowry is also demographically dependent. In some regions of country (like H.P), dowry is a totally alien thing, while in many other regions, there is just noway an arranged marriage could be arranged without dowry, so it varies..... But yes, that's the way to go forward, grooms' sides have to understand that demanding dowry is akin to looting someone else's money at gun-point. Most times, brides' families have no choice, they have to find a match within their community and its an extremely difficult choice if they chose to leave their daughters unmarried due to NOT being able to find any suitable dowry-less match......
      So its quite tricky, and somehow grooms' families have to be convinced on this matter. Interesting fact is that, in many cases, groom's families take dowry on a stupid tit-for-tat ground, i.e. "I gave dowry in my daughter's marriage, so I will take dowry in my boy's marriage". And you are left with no argument when its the opposite- "I will take dowry in my son's marriage because afterall, after that, I have to shell out an equally large amount in my daughter's marriage!!"

      So its quite complex. A fine, effective solution will emerge only with the collective response of society, when an entire community or region decides NOT to take or give dowry. Administration can only enforce laws, but its WE, who decides what happens around us in our society. So this change can be brought about only by the awakening of civil society, common men.... only deep realization in society can sort it out, and that would take some time I guess... We should work together to accelerate the process.

      Delete
  5. You have a great blog here, written with passion. Lot of details you have given and did not stop with the problems rather went on with giving solution. that's nice. I am happy that stay free brought this challenge and gave an opportunity to read such blogs. I wish you "all the best" to win this contest so that more will come to know of your blog. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Heyy, thanks a ton for appreciating my post. and yes, problems are known to most, only that they are clueless about the solutions, so I tried my best to put up some good solutions too. And did you mean, my post deserves winning! :) well, that would be definitely a great thing, but as of now, I wish that more and more people read this blog-post, so that more people think about this grave issue.
      and thanks a lot for your wishes :)

      Delete
  6. I am so glad you took up this issue...in fact just thinking about the number of things that we have to change before we can change this has my head reeling...hopefully more youths like you guys can make a difference...all the best for the contest btw and thanks for such a lovely comment on my blog...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Karishma Ji, Its really nice to see you here :) Appreciation from people like you feels truly blessing. And yes, you got it right, to change the rampant female foeticide, we really need to change so many other things, so yes, its a very difficult task, but together we can do so. So spread the issue, talk about it with others, and let's try to bring the change....
      BTW, thanks a lot for your wishes, and commenting on your post was entirely my pleasure, your post deserves lots of appreciation, you too have a raised a very important issue.. all the best! :)

      Delete
  7. It's great you took up this issue, we have to first look at changing the age old horrendous practices and then only anything beyond can take a step further.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks for appreciating :) and yes, we need to change the age-old practices, for this the mindset of people would need to be changed, hope more and more people join hands and collectively we can bring about this change in mindset of people :)

      Delete
  8. Loved this blog post on a very burning issue.. the latest victim being Baby Afreen, who was not cared for by those who should have loved her... I tried to express my own anguish on my blog.. do drop in if you find time..
    http://under-the-tree-of-tranquility.blogspot.com/2012/04/love-them.html

    As you pointed out, dowry is one issue, but unfortunately it shall not go away since most parents feel this is a guarantee that their daughter will be looked after in her new home. They fear that if she is send off without anything she might not be welcomed wholeheartedly. It is also seen as a financial net for their daughter. But it can change if the younger generation comes forward with more determination. But more than dowry it is the following that needs more focus:

    You have already mentioned the same on your blog..

    A medieval thinking that a boy child carries the family name (generation) forward but girl child can't!!

    A (mis)conception that only a boy child can perform the last riots properly, helping parents gain salvation!!

    I have been thinking about this after many reports that says that it is the affluent who are now killing their girld child.

    Why?

    Dowry should not be an issue and if the mother is financially independant and educated too, she sure does have a voice over her child.

    As one commentor mentioned on my blog, more than men it is the women who can help in this matter. It is they who have to come forward to help their own kind. It is they who have to overcome their love for the boy child over the girl child.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Happy Kitten, it feels nice to know that you liked my blog-post. thanks a lot for expressing your views here. and yes, as you mentioned, "more than men it is the women who can help in this matter".
      But problem is that women themselves play a role in this heinous crime, may be they don't have the guts or capability to oppose it, that's why I have also written- "What can be more ironic than the fact that female population is working to finish off their own gender!!"
      As for affluent families killing their girl child, I think other mentioned factors must be in play-the patriarchal mentality, and the preference for male child due to those few mentioned reasons. We should try to change the mentality of society, especially the grown up people who play deciding role in these things, its difficult for sure but we must try our best... thanks for visiting and expressing your views :)

      Delete
  9. Nicely written..I hope it will be in the winners list for sure..
    Well done yaar..cheers for the article :).
    Also Check out mine.Give your comment on it.
    Are Hijra's(TransGender) not a Human being.?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hence proved...I ain't the only one who researches his stuff so that his posts pack a punch!!!!:-D Awesome work done on this post.I liked the way you described your own personal feelings on the issue throughout the post.Research is spot on.Narration tight.:-) Best of luck,bro!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot for that kind of appreciation :) and well, sorry to say, I didn't do any research specifically to write this post. I read a lot and I had already read all those things I have given link of. All I did was noted what I wanted to mention (and quote), then I just googled the link for those quotes/reports and attached it with my post :) and yes, this issue is quite close to my heart, glad that you noticed and appreciated the description of my personal feelings on the issue :) :)
      thanks for visiting, and best of luck to you too... :)

      Delete
  11. nice work..wish you luck ahead dear!! :)

    ReplyDelete